The film opens with a young girl running through a graveyard, crying, her face covered with skull paint. She makes it to her house and her parents ask her what's wrong. The little girl, named Sandy, responds by stating, "I don't remember." Years later, Sandy Channing and her brother, Eli, are both academic students. They go to a party at night at their friend T.J.'s house, and they and their friends go to the graveyard to play a game. As they are about to start, a girl about their age asks to play. They allow her, and they play a different version of tag, where one of them is a ghost, and whoever the ghost tags becomes a ghost until there is one left. As Sandy tells the new girl that she's won, the girl asks if she remembers her. Sandy tells her she doesn't, with the girl stating, "You will," before jumping from the cliff behind her.